Meet Our Team

Alyson Gerlach

Email: alysong@stjoebay.com

General Manager/Broker

Alyson, a native of Port St. Joe, joined Pristine Properties, LLC in December 2003. After completing a bachelor's degree at Florida State University, she decided to move back to this area because of her love for the beach.

Alyson brings excitement and enthusiasm to our company and will dedicate that energy to all of your real estate needs. Please stop by and talk with Alyson or call her at our office to discuss your plans on purchasing or selling your Home or Property.

Natalie Shoaf

Phone: 850-227-4355
Email: NatalieShoaf@gmail.com

As a consistent multi-million-dollar producer, I bring over 24 years of real estate expertise in Gulf and Franklin Counties, specializing in residential, vacant land, and commercial properties. Real estate isn’t just my career, it’s my passion.

Navigating flood zones, wetlands, and building codes can be complex, but that’s where I come in. I’m committed to making sure my clients understand every factor that may impact their transaction. Whether you're buying or selling, I provide the knowledge, transparency, and professionalism you deserve.

Deeply rooted in this community, I have actively served on the Boards of Directors for the Realtors Association (past President), the Historic Port Theatre, and the Gulf County Chamber of Commerce. I love this unique area of Florida; I would love to share my knowledge with you.

My commitment level has helped build a remarkable track record with hundreds of Five Star Reviews. Let me help you with your Real Estate needs. Call/Text me at 850-227-4355 or email NatalieShoaf@gmail.com

Mary Ann

As a Licensed Real Estate agent with a strong background in finance, I am passionate about helping individuals and families find their dream homes and navigate the complexities of property transactions. My commitment to exceptional customer service and my in-depth knowledge of the local market empower me to deliver tailored solutions that meet my clients’ unique needs.

In addition to my real estate expertise, I am also a licensed Residential Contractor. This dual certification enables me to offer clients a comprehensive prospective on property value, renovation potential, and construction processes. My hands-on experience in the construction industry enhances my ability to advise clients on properties that require renovations or improvements, ensuring they make informed decisions on their investments.

I believe in building lasting relationships with my clients, grounded in trust and transparency. Whether you are looking to buy, sell, or renovate a property, I am dedicated to providing personalized support every step of the way.

Joyce Baxley

Email: joyceb@stjoebay.com

A native of Connecticut, Joyce knew the minute she dug her toes into the pristine white sands of our beautiful beaches this would be her home. Joyce relocated to Franklin County in 1969 and finished high school.

After graduating, she was employed for 24 years by St. Joe Paper Co. until the closing of the mill in 1998. She graduated in 2001 Summa Cum Laude with an A.S. Degree in Business from Gulf Coast Community College.

Joyce brings to our team not only an innate love for this area, but 28 years experience in business and accounting. Joyce recently received her Real Estate License and looks forward to meeting with you for all your Real Estate needs.

Justin Gerlach

Email: justing@stjoebay.com

A native of the Port St Joe area, I returned to join Pristine Properties in 2003 a few years after graduating from the University of Florida. Heading our sister company, Pristine Properties Vacation Rentals, for over 20 years along with an extensive background in residential new construction, gives me a unique perspective to find you the perfect spot to start new or locate the beach vacation property you've been looking for. I look forward to making you a part of what makes this area so special.